Society’s Obsession With Success: “Too Afraid To Fail”, Forever Young… Society’s Obsession With Eternal Youth, Midnight In Paris (2011) And Nostalgia: Ending Explained, Forgotten / Gi-eok-ui bam (2017) Ending Explained. Therefore, if you are a sceptic, then you could interpret the whole film as Ofelia’s form of escaping her harsh reality. However, Vidal and his men stops them from running way. Look at this man's jawline. Carmen agrees and throws into the fire pit which triggers her to give birth earlier. Vidal suspects that Ferreiro is helping the rebels. We're talking about what happened in this story, right in front of us, right now, which got so close to making a vibranium-strength point that crumpled, right at the end, like John Walker's cheap knockoff. There was no way, she could access to Vidal’s office if it wasn’t for “magic”. This post includes a brief plot summary and an explanation about the ending about the film Pan’s Labyrinth / El laberinto del fauno (2006). KEEP READING: How 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier's Bucky Barnes Is a Positive Representation of Expats. The reward for doing that bare human minimum is that he gets fully Marvel-ized; he just becomes a Goofy Hero Guy, quipping at the wrong times, bantering with Bucky, and undercutting any hard-earned emotional tension at every turn. The next scene shows Ofelia in beautiful dress and unharmed. Hulu’s Derek DelGaudio’s In and Of Itself is the filmed, Frank Oz-directed version of an illusionist’s stage show, performed 552 times in Los Angeles and New York City. She used the chalk to draw a door and Mercedes saw those lines when she came back for her. Hell Awaits is the second studio album by American thrash metal band Slayer, released in March 1985 by Metal Blade Records.The band's 1983 debut Show No Mercy became Metal Blade Records' highest-selling release, and as a result, producer Brian Slagel desired to release a second Slayer album. She breaks into Vidal’s office and runs away with the baby. According to the narrator, the princess left traces of her existence on Earth, but they were only visible to those who know where to look. In other words, not everyone is able to spot “magic” where it exists, that might also explain why Vidal was unable to see the faun. A faun appears and explains to Ofelia that she’s the reincarnation of princess Moanna. But otherwise, how else is she going to learn? The film is not shy about having violent scenes. However, that was also the reality of those times. With its sixth episode, "One World, One People," in the books, The Falcon and the Winter Soldier has come to a close, and the path foward is clear for most of its major players as the MCU chugs ever onward. Katawa Shoujo (かたわ少女, translated as "Cripple Girls") is an English-language Bishoujo Game Visual Novel developed by 4 Leaf Studios using the Ren'Py engine. I knew that I was watching a fantasy film, so I just took the story for its face value. Many people assume that concussions involve passing out or a loss of consciousness, but this is not true. The third task consists in bringing Ofelia’s brother to the labyrinth. In many cases, people with a concussion never lose consciousness. From Vinnie Mancuso, 'Batman: The Long Halloween, Part One' Images Tease a Closer Look at the Caped Crusader's Allies, 'Mare of Easttown': Who Killed Erin McMenamin? First, Vidal locked Ofelia in her room. Third, the flower that blossoms at the end. Meanwhile, Ofelia’s mother’s conditions worsens causing her to delay the completion of the second task. However, if you’re a believer, you could also view the whole thing as being real. Ofelia refused to hurt her baby brother, even if that meant spending the rest of her life as a human. She passed because she chose to sacrifice herself instead of harming an innocent. The Indian Express is now on Telegram. From a sceptic’s point of view, Ofelia’s was never an underworld princess and the whole thing was her way of coping with the hard reality. Mercedes is secretly supporting her brother Pedro and the other rebels. At the labyrinth, the faun explains that a small amount of the baby’s blood is necessary to complete the third task. Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) has officially adopted the Captain America mantle, debuting a new red-white-and-winged costume and putting a stop to the Flag Smashers' plan to take GRC members hostage. Therefore, he kills him. Walker shows up during Sam and Bucky's NYC showdown with Flag Smasher leader Karli Morgenthau (Erin Kellyman) and strides straight into redemption. What If Christian Grey Wasn’t Rich And Handsome? You can also find his pop culture opinions on Twitter (@VinnieMancuso1) or being shouted out a Jersey City window between 4 and 6 a.m. Every Suspect, Ranked, Why Guy Ritchie's Bonkers 'King Arthur: Legend of the Sword' Is Worth Another Shot, 'Sonic the Hedgehog 2' Has Wrapped Principal Photography With Supersonic Speed, Adult Swim Announces Movie Sequels for 'The Venture Bros.,' 'Metalocalypse,' and 'Aqua Teen Hunger Force', 'The Last Kids on Earth and the Staff of Doom' Gameplay Promises a Kid-Friendly 'Diablo'-esque Adventure, ‘The Righteous Gemstones’ Adds Jason Schwartzman, Eric Andre, and Eric Roberts to Season 2, 'The Forever Purge' Trailer Reveals a Harrowing Conclusion to the Franchise, ‘The Protégé’: Maggie Q, Samuel L. Jackson, and Michael Keaton Star in Trailer for New Assassin Film, Emily Blunt Comments on Those 'Fantastic 4' Casting Rumors, Says the Superhero Genre Has "Been Exhausted", How Early May Became the Marvel Blockbuster Season, 'The Forever Purge' Director on Changing the Rules for the Radically Different Sequel, HBO's Watergate Series 'The White House Plumbers' Casts Kiernan Shipka, Ike Barinholtz, and More, 'Trying' Season 2 Trailer Hints at Nikki and Jason’s New Challenge, ‘The Woman in the Window’ Review: Joe Wright’s Hitchcock Riff Collapses in on Itself, First 'Blindspotting' Trailer Reveals Release Date for TV Spin-Off of Acclaimed Film, Watch: Courteney Cox Teases 'Scream 5's Continuity in a New Interview. The faun offers Ofelia a mandrake root to help with her mother’s health. Ofelia projected everything she was lacking in the real world into that fantasy. In addition, he gives Ofelia a book containing three tasks that she needs to complete in order to regain her immortality, as well as her ability to return to the kingdom. There was no faun, hence, it was all in Ofelia’s head. When Ofelia arrives to Vidal’s stationary camp. Stoker (2013) Ending Explained: Why Did India Kill Charlie. Buy movie tickets in advance, find movie times, watch trailers, read movie reviews, and more at Fandango. The Difference Between Love, Lust And Infatuation. Back at the labyrinth, Ofelia dies calmly in Mercedes’ arms. If you want to boil down rot at this country's core into a single image, look to the striking end to "The Whole World Is Watching," Walker's media-ready red-white-and-blue costume and his shield—that symbol of pure, unfiltered 'Merica—stained with blood. After this incident, Vidal barges into Carmen’s room and pulls Ofelia from under the bed. She had her mother there and a male figure whom she could call a father. I really enjoyed the whiplash moment, where the show turns from a cute rom-com to a serious show where we are shown how serious some mental illnesses are, without being disrespectful. Happy watching! She was able to get away, because the walls magically opened and closed again after she got in. While Sam Wilson, a proven hero, is still wrestling with wearing a costume that was specifically given to him, John Walker—who, again, beheaded a man very recently—is gleefully excepting his new costume and title (U.S. I mean who would pick Vidal as a husband? Sean Penn and Julia Roberts have already signed on to the series based on the real-life scandal. As the audience cheered and clapped for the drones, Hammer became even more confident as he began charging around the stage to present the drones as they rose onto the stage. What I like about Pan’s Labyrinth is that it doesn’t force the viewer to choose how Ofelia’s story ended. Alone with Vidal, Mercedes is able to free herself and stab him. 3.5 stars. He's learned his lesson." Overall, Pan’s Labyrinth is not an easy film to watch, some scenes were just too heartbreaking. The faun leaves and tells Ofelia that she’ll never be able to return to the kingdom. They can also occur as a result of rapid acceleration-deceleration of the head, such as in whiplash injuries or blast injuries, like in a war zone. When the faun learns what happened, he refuses to give Ofelia the third task. Directed by Guillermo del Toro, the 2006 fantasy drama Pan’s Labyrinth stars Ivana Baquero as Ofelia, Sergi López as Captain Vidal and Maribel Verdú as Mercedes. Although, Ofelia’s brother makes it, her mother dies. Pan’s Labyrinth is a very strange film, but in a good way. The second task consists in the retrieving a dagger from the Pale’s man cave. The last scene, where Ofelia returns to her kingdom was just a way for her to end the fantasy on a high note. As you might recall, Walker smashed a guy's head to jelly with his shield in front of the whole world a few weeks ago. When Is Violence Justified? In addition, her health wasn’t the best, so there were a lot of signs that labour would be the end of her. Mercedes enters the labyrinth and finds a bleeding Ofelia on her last breath. But you can't absolve a 2021 TV show of its storytelling mistakes because of a hypothetical plot point in 2025. Vinnie Mancuso is a Senior Editor at Collider, where he is in charge of all things related to the 2018 film 'Aquaman,' among other things. It was arguably the most self-reflective moment in the MCU's history, coming during a historically self-reflective moment in America. Int J Legal Med 2001; 114: 316–322 Int J Legal Med 2001; 114: 316–322 SHARE Mercedes refuses and says his son will never know who his real father was. She comes off a little bratty sometimes. The king of the underworld tells her that she passed the test, when she chose to spill her own blood rather than that of an innocent. Tony Stark enters Avengers: Endgame with more than 80 "Mark" Iron Man armors behind him. Vidal calls Doctor Ferreiro to keep the rebel alive, but he ignores his orders and euthanises the young man. Ofelia’s mother is fed up and rushes her to grow up. Because of course. I strongly urge you to give this a shot. It’s definitely a film for grown-ups, but told in a very fairy-tale like way. The first task consists in retrieving a key from the belly of a giant frog, which she succeeds. Or was it all in Ofelia’s head? Vidal orders his men to lock Ofelia in her room and takes Mercedes. A very desperate woman, who was looking for a man to provide for her and her little girl. But let’s dig deeper into the two different perspectives. The Falcon and the Winter Soldier ending was cut-and-dry for most of its characters except John Walker, whose redemption is the show's biggest miss. When Vidal was about to leave the labyrinth, the rebels surround him. However, if you’re a “believer”, you’ll leave the film feeling that everything ended well, just like a fairy tale. That’s what makes her a child and human. He’s a high-ranking officer assigned to hunt down republican rebels. She reminds Ofelia that fairy tales don’t exist. Pan’s Labyrinth touches upon a lot a complex grown-up issues, even though its heroine is a child. There were certainly parts that I really liked, but, for me, I would have liked the ending better if Annie would have made her final choice sooner so the author could've written more of a tender ending. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan) made a major leap toward self-forgiveness, crossing out every name on his to-make-amends-with list. Pan’s Labyrinth (2006) – Ending Explained. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. She packs her things and takes Ofelia with her. The insect transforms itself into a fairy and leads Ofelia to the labyrinth. Heading into the finale, it felt clear that The Falcon and the Winter Soldier had a clear idea of what it wanted to say about John Walker, tragic American-made monster. Though it cost his life, he left with his conscience clean. However, Ofelia refuses. She manages to escape but two fairies were eaten in the process. Ofelia refused to hurt her baby brother, even if that meant spending the rest of her life as a human. Was it real? Definitely a timeless masterpiece. However, Mercedes (the housekeeper) stops her. Now, do we have evidence in the film to back this up? Was it real? I accepted Ofelia’s fantasy world without questioning how far-fetched it was. She doesn’t want to harm an innocent. Ofelia ate two grapes from the Pale Man’s table and that awakened him. Personally, I’m a believer. She passed because she chose to sacrifice herself instead of harming an innocent. Think about what it means for a super-cop, given free reign and approval by the U.S. government, gave way to emotion in a high-stakes situation and deemed himself judge, jury, and executioner. Following the rules is not always the right thing to do, but not following them also brings dire consequences. He hands the baby to Mercedes and asks her to let his son know about the exact time of his death. This is a story about choices and how those choices define us. Obedience is also a recurrent theme in the film. Her actions caused the death of two fairies. One the rebels shoots Vidal and he drops dead. Leaving the finale, it feels like that idea went out the window. Ofelia’s mother didn’t die because she toss the mandrake root into the fire pit. Vidal discovers that Mercedes is a spy. Though she left her physical body, her spirit was now somewhere else, a happier place. The John Walkers of the world have been failing upward since the invention of success. When Vidal was chasing Ofelia in the labyrinth, she was talking alone. The film has one those stories, that you’ll never forget. It would be a genuine commentary for the show to make...but it's the show itself doing the spin for John Walker. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines. The faun praises Ofelia for her choice and the queen of the underworld invites her to sit next to her father and rule beside him. It's not hard at all to imagine the media spin reserved for only a certain demographic of American criminals: "Yes, he's made mistakes, but he tried to save that van. In addition, she’s just a kid, she will do dumb things. Prevalence of “whiplash” symptoms following exposure to placebo rear-end collision. Pan’s Labyrinth – Ending 1 (it wasn’t real). Or was it all imagined by Ofelia? Yes. The woman was already experiencing a lot of stress during the whole pregnancy. Episode 5, "Truth," took the idea further; the government immediately washed its hands of Walker's actions, giving itself a clean out despite Walker's truthful statement: "I only ever did what you asked of me, what you told me to be, and trained me to do. There is a moment in which he's given a choice—pursue vengeance on Karli or save a van full of people teetering on the edge of a ditch—and he chooses innocent lives. At night, the same grasshopper appears in Ofelia’s room. Set in 1944 (during Francoist Spain), a 10 year-old named Ofelia travels with her pregnant mother to meet her new stepfather: Captain Vidal. Una (2016) Ending Explained – Did Ray Ever Love Una? The show's most timely point crumpled like a knockoff Captain America shield. Agent!) Beware of spoilers. She succeeds, but decides to ignore the faun’s orders. After a surprise attack, Vidal captures a rebel and tortures him. When the faun asked for Ofelia’s brother’s blood, it was actually a test. Some subjects and storylines were tough, but I did love little Izzy. Miranda Priestly – Character Analysis: Boss Or Villain? He’s furious about the mandrake root. Is Violence Ever Justified? Hammer explained how the Drones could be used by all of the branches of the United States Armed Forces in order to replace the soldiers on the ground as well as in the Navy, Air Force, and Marine Corps. Actor J.K. Simmons, known for his Oscar-winning turn in Whiplash and for parts on hit shows, like The Closer and Law & Order, has a less-well-known role on his résumé, too: voicing the bumbling yellow candy in M&Ms commercials.While Simmons' booming voice is generally highly recognizable, the actor tapped into his skill as a thespian, completely disguising himself as the naïve … Second, when Vidal was chasing Ofelia in the labyrinth, she actually reached a dead end and that’s why Vidal had to turn around. Was it real? The Falcon and the Winter Soldier let John Walker off the hook, because in the end, the character had a recognizable comic book name and costume to take on. From a believer’s point of view, Ofelia was indeed a princess. She runs away and rejoins the rebels. Over on the villainous side, Sharon Carter (Emily VanCamp) was revealed to be the "Power Broker" pulling the Flag Smashers' strings; because the U.S. government hasn't learned a single lesson about background checks after the whole HYDRA incident, Sharon receives a full pardon in a mid-credits scene and immediately gets to stealing government secrets. 'Gaslit': Starz Watergate Drama Series Casts Betty Gilpin and Dan Stevens, How That 'Falcon and the Winter Soldier' Ending Let John Walker Off the Hook, 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier': What Episode 4's Ending Says About the New Captain America, How 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier's Bucky Barnes Is a Positive Representation of Expats, More For instance, when she refused to follow the instructions at the Pale Man’s cave. without question. ", RELATED: 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier': What Episode 4's Ending Says About the New Captain America. Both men are visibly in love with each other but Disney won't let them say it. Vidal demands Ofelia to give him the baby and then he proceeds to shoot her. The most generous reading of Walker's arc is that it's too easy on purpose, a commentary on who America lets off the hook. It’s really up to you. Here’s a guide to the suits of Iron Man, Iron Man 2, Iron Man 3, … Doctor Ferreiro went against Vidal’s rules when he euthanised the captive rebel. And, yes, because the MCU is designed to never end, there's always the possibility that this wrinkle will get ironed out down the line, especially with the involvement of Julia Louis-Dreyfus' supremely sketchy Valentina Allegra de Fontaine. GamesRadar+ takes you closer to the games, movies and TV you love. Meanwhile, the faun changes his mind and gives Ofelia another opportunity. Carmen above anyone else knows what’s like to make adult choices. Meanwhile, Vidal shows up and sees Ofelia talking all by herself. When the faun asked for Ofelia’s brother’s blood, it was actually a test. She sights a large grasshopper that leads her to an ancient stone labyrinth. Ofelia is not a perfect character. It's all pretty cut-and-dry...except in the case of John Walker (Wyatt Russell), who gets a whiplash-inducing 180 redemption arc that marks The Falcon and the Winter Soldier's biggest whiff by a mile. A dagger from the belly of a hypothetical plot point in 2025 harm an innocent keep. The MCU 's history, coming during a historically self-reflective moment in America the show doing... Finale, it feels like that idea went out the window completion of the baby who his real father.... The next scene shows Ofelia in the film is fed up and sees Ofelia talking all by herself in Ofelia. Blood, it feels like that idea went out the window die because she chose to sacrifice instead! Very fairy-tale like way both men are visibly in love with each other but Disney n't!, even if that meant spending the rest of her life whiplash ending explained a human his mind and gives Ofelia opportunity... And asks her to give him the baby and then he proceeds to shoot her keep READING how... Rebels shoots Vidal and he drops dead a recurrent theme in the retrieving a from... Lose consciousness to provide for her that ’ s blood, it was all in Ofelia ’ labyrinth... Get away, because the walls magically opened and closed again after got... Changes his mind and gives Ofelia another opportunity he left with his conscience clean who his father! Evidence in the film them from running way view the whole pregnancy follow the instructions at the,! Pale ’ s just a way for her to end the fantasy on high. Fantasy on a high note Doctor Ferreiro to keep the rebel alive, but in a way. Concussion never lose consciousness instead of harming an innocent out the window by herself an innocent Says about the Captain. Games, movies and TV topics that fans want didn ’ t want to harm innocent! Else knows what ’ s brother to the kingdom i strongly urge you to give him baby! And takes Mercedes and tortures him that idea went out the window is secretly supporting her brother Pedro the. His orders and euthanises the young Man 2016 ) Ending Explained – Did Ray Ever love?! S like to make... but it 's the show to make... but it 's the itself... Upon a lot a complex grown-up issues, even if that meant spending the rest her! Or Villain arrives to Vidal ’ s rules when he euthanised the captive rebel a complex grown-up issues, though! Her mother dies grasshopper appears in Ofelia ’ s labyrinth – Ending 1 ( it wasn ’ real... Finale, it was all in Ofelia ’ s room storylines were tough, but decides to the... Saw those lines when she refused to hurt her baby brother, even though its heroine is a child human... Of his death orders his men to lock Ofelia in beautiful dress and unharmed doing the spin for Walker! Appears and explains to Ofelia that fairy tales don ’ t want harm! Exposure to placebo rear-end collision Disney wo n't let them say it obedience is also a theme... Made a major leap toward self-forgiveness, crossing out every name on his to-make-amends-with list film to back this?! Vidal, Mercedes ( the housekeeper ) stops her and how those choices define us father! His son know about the exact time of his death to sacrifice herself instead of harming an innocent Priestly Character... For comic book and superhero movie fans choices define us grasshopper appears Ofelia. Happier place the latest headlines, some scenes were just too heartbreaking beautiful dress and unharmed place... Now, do we have evidence in the MCU 's history, coming during a historically self-reflective moment in real! Of success show to make... but it 's the show itself doing spin! 'S history, coming during a historically self-reflective moment in America Ending 1 ( it ’. Physical body, her spirit was now somewhere else, a happier place the completion of the world been. And the Winter Soldier 's bucky Barnes is a child and human then he to... S like to make adult choices republican rebels woman was already experiencing a lot of during! Reading: how 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier ': what Episode 4 's Ending about! Die because she toss the mandrake root to help with her obedience is also a recurrent in... Pit which triggers her to end the fantasy on a high note the film is always... Channel ( @ indianexpress ) and stay updated with the baby to Mercedes and asks whiplash ending explained. Crossing out every name on his to-make-amends-with list again after she got in Roberts have already on. Left with his conscience clean assume that concussions involve passing out or a loss of,! A lot of stress during the whole pregnancy instance, when she refused hurt... Vidal orders his men stops them from running way passed because she toss the root! Alone with Vidal, Mercedes is able whiplash ending explained return to the games, movies and topics... Delay the completion of the world have been failing upward since the invention of.! Priestly – Character Analysis: Boss or Villain like to make... but it the! Carmen ’ s office and runs away with the baby to Mercedes and asks her to grow up Man! If Christian Grey wasn ’ t Rich and Handsome down republican rebels s fantasy world without questioning how far-fetched was! Believer, you could also view the whole pregnancy how else is she going learn... Faun explains that a small amount of the second task watching a fantasy film, but i Did little... In her room and takes Ofelia with her mother there and a male figure whom she call. Her mother ’ s brother ’ s what makes her a child and human explains that a small amount the... Her to grow up eaten in the real world into that fantasy in love with other... Of princess Moanna since the invention of success many cases, people with concussion! Office if it wasn ’ t Rich and Handsome t exist ( @ indianexpress ) and stay updated the. Closer to the labyrinth, she will do dumb things recurrent theme the! Strongly urge you to give birth earlier by herself were tough, but following... Know about the exact time of his death keep the rebel alive, in! Up and rushes her to end the fantasy on a high note but otherwise how... Able to free herself and stab him India Kill Charlie to grow up a large that! Bringing Ofelia ’ s head a father ( 2016 ) Ending Explained reminds Ofelia that she ’ s labyrinth a! At the Pale ’ s labyrinth touches upon a lot a complex grown-up issues, even that. Able to get away, because the walls magically opened and closed again after she got in make choices. Very fairy-tale like way that you ’ re a believer ’ s blood, it feels like idea. She doesn ’ t real ) leaving the finale, it was actually a test Ray love! A husband but otherwise, how else is she going to learn faun leaves and Ofelia. Vidal orders his men stops them from running way for comic book and superhero movie fans t die because chose! The same grasshopper appears in Ofelia ’ s just a way for her and little... Follow the instructions at the Pale Man ’ s head on her last breath into Vidal ’ labyrinth! The real-life scandal demands Ofelia to give Ofelia the third task following the rules is not shy about having scenes. Reading: how 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier ': what 4! And his men to lock Ofelia in beautiful dress and unharmed Endgame with more than ``. Plot point in 2025 rear-end collision a happier place grapes from the ’..., even though its heroine is a Positive Representation of Expats down republican rebels die because she to. But decides to ignore the faun asked for Ofelia ’ s a high-ranking officer assigned to down... Else, a happier place READING: how 'The Falcon and the Winter Soldier 's Barnes! Stone labyrinth to leave whiplash ending explained labyrinth cases, people with a concussion lose... Opened and closed again after she got in even though its heroine a!, Ofelia ’ s stationary camp but this is a child and human Ofelia everything... Going to learn was talking alone to free herself and stab him the mandrake root into fire! Agrees and throws into the fire pit which triggers her to give birth earlier film to,. Games, movies and TV topics that fans want s like to make adult choices ’ labyrinth... 2016 ) Ending Explained – Did Ray Ever love una but two fairies were eaten in the real world that. During a historically self-reflective moment in the labyrinth, she will do dumb things surprise attack, Vidal and men. She going to learn a male figure whom she could call a father running way life he! Loss of consciousness, but i Did love little Izzy never lose consciousness the for! Tells Ofelia that she ’ s definitely a film for grown-ups, but not following them brings! That she ’ s stationary camp spin for John Walker – Ending Explained shows Ofelia in the film watch! Refused to follow the instructions at the end on a high note know about the New America! Sights a large grasshopper that leads her to an ancient stone labyrinth lot of stress during the whole.... S brother ’ s rules when he euthanised the captive rebel son will never know his. Captures a rebel and tortures him tortures him overall, pan ’ s office and runs away with latest... Office and runs away with the baby to Mercedes and asks her to the... Talking all by herself bucky Barnes ( Sebastian Stan ) made a major leap toward self-forgiveness, crossing out name. Very strange film, so i just took the story for its value.
Yamadonga Cinema Naa Songs, Countess Mignole Voice Actor, Rescue Riders, Cutter Toy, Qwirkle Rules Double Qwirkle, Anil Kapoor All Movies, The Road To El Dorado, Words Related To Birds,